Daily Archives: October 9, 2012


CIT v Pelican Investments (P.) Ltd. [ITA No: 3424 of 2010 dtd 21 August 2012] Bombay High Court Background: The assessee by an agreement dated 7th November, 1984 with Hotel Leelaventure Limited (HLL) was granted a licence to occupy a shopping arcade for a period of 11 years. The assessee was required to pay to HLL, compensation for the said licence commencing from the date of occupation certificate, at the rate of Rs. 150/- per sq. mtr. per month during the period of the licence. Thereafter, the assessee and HLL entered into a fresh agreement dated 24th January, 1999, by which HLL granted the assessee further licence in respect of the same premises for a period of 10 years. The assessee filed its return of income on 29th October, 2006 for , declaring a total loss of Rs. 48,626/-. The AO made an order under section 143(3). The annual value under section 23(1)(a) was computed at Rs. 60,27,027/-. A deduction under section 24 at 30% amounting to Rs. 18,08,108/- was allowed. The AO, accordingly, assessed a sum of Rs. 42,18,919/- to be income from house property.

In the absence of renewal clause in the lease agreement, subsequent agreement cannot be merged ...